Beatrix Campbell

Beatrix Campbell
Born Mary Lorimer Beatrix Barnes
February 3, 1947 (1947-02-03) (age 65)
Carlisle
Residence France
Nationality British
Political party Green party
Political movement Marxist feminism
Spouse Bobby Campbell
Partner Judith Jones

Mary Lorimer Beatrix Campbell, OBE (born 3 February 1947)[1] is a British campaigning journalist and author. Since the mid 1970s, she has published numerous articles and book reviews in such publications as Marxism Today, Red Rag, Time Out, Feminist Review, New Statesman, New Socialist, The Guardian, The Independent, Scotland on Sunday, The Scotsman and the Sunday Mirror. She describes herself as a communist feminist.[2][3] She was born in Carlisle and was one of the founders of Red Rag.[4]

Her books include Wigan Pier Revisited (winner of the Cheltenham Festival Literary Prize); films include Listen to the Children, a documentary about the watershed Nottingham child abuse case; and Dangerous Places, Diana Princess of Wales - How Sexual Politics Shook the Monarchy.

Contents

Early life

Born Mary Lorimer Beatrix Barnes in Carlisle, England. She was educated at Harraby Secondary Modern School and Carlisle and County High School for Girls.[5] Her parents, Jim and Catherine, were Communist Party members and she had a sister, Tini, and a younger brother, Jimmy who also became a Communist.[6][7] Campbell failed her A-levels.[8]

Personal life

Campbell was married to the Morning Star journalist Bobby Campbell, a folk musician who went on to work at The Scotsman in the 1970s.[9][10] At the age of 23, while still married, she came out as a lesbian.[2] Her partner is Judith Jones, with whom she has co-authored a book, Stolen Voices (withdrawn under libel laws), and a play, All the Children Cried.[11] She lives in France.[12]

Political development

Campbell joined the Communist Party of Great Britain around the time it was turning itself from a bulwark of trade union officialdom towards a more feminist and multi-culturalist programme. She joined a reform faction founded by university lecturer Bill Warren in 1970[13] and was one of the 'Gramscians' who "took leading positions in the party"[14] when she joined the National Women's Advisory Committee. She worked as a sub-editor on the Morning Star newspaper, with critics noting she received state subsidised holidays to Communist East Germany during this time and praised the country.[15]

At that time, Campbell excused the party membership's identification with Stalinist oppression in Eastern Europe: "… in the main it is a solidly working class part of the Party which is called Stalinist … only by virtue of the fact that they thought the CIA was about to take over Czechoslovakia and it was therefore politically correct that the Russians moved in." However, Campbell did use the label 'Stalinist' as a negative, but what she meant by 'Stalinist' was those elements in the Communist Party who criticised the line put forward by its leadership. So she condemned the "Stalinists in the party who have actually realised a position which is a very comprehensive criticism of where the leadership is going".[16]

In 1977 Campbell defended the Communist Party's revolutionary credentials: "There is no way it is legitimate to say that the party isn’t revolutionary... the defeats, the comings and goings doesn’t make it an organisation that sells out the masses."[17]

In 1984 Campbell suggested that rising unemployment would lead to the criminalisation of young men: "the form of boys' masculinity constitutes them as folk devils, a 'danger to society' ... they generate a kind of moral panic ... symbolised by the social nuisance of big bad boys who bite social workers".[18] Seven years later, though, Campbell lost her critical distance on the criminalisation of young men reporting rioting in Blackbird Leys: "The riots of 1991 were driven not by pain but by pride, the vanity of fragile masculinity... Some of the 'bad boys' have just made some crap estates even worse."[19]

As Campbell's distaste for the mob intensified, her attitude to the forces of law and order softened. Her sympathetic interview with Derbyshire Chief Constable John Newing was titled 'A Fair Cop'.[20]

In September 2008, she applied for membership of the Women's National Commission, a government quango set up to speak on behalf of UK women, and was successful.[21]

In July 2009, writing for The Guardian she wrote in support of surveillance of the public and vetting of authors before allowing them to present to children in schools.[22]

In October 2009, she was announced as the Green Party Parliamentary candidate for Hampstead and Kilburn stating "We put at the absolute centre of our policies, the sustainability of social relationships and the need for a fundamentally fair society. We stand for social justice, respect and equality between the genders and the generations. And we don’t think that slicing public services to ribbons can be the way forward for British society."[23]

Child abuse controversies

In Marxism Today, Campbell protested that "anyone who respects children's accounts of child abuse aren't taken seriously," and for some reason professionals were reluctant to believe that Satanists were "organising rituals to penetrate any orifice available in troops of little children; to cut open rabbits or cats or people and drink their blood; to shit on silver trays and make the children eat it."[24]

In 1998 Campbell reported on the Newcastle City Council report into allegations of child abuse at the Shieldfield Nursery in the city in 1993. She claimed the council inquiry was "stringent" and had found "persuasive evidence of sadistic and sexual abuse of up to 350 children". The alleged perpetrators were workers at the nursery, Dawn Reed and Christopher Lillie, who had already been cleared of multiple charges in a criminal trial in 1994. They subsequently successfully sued the Council, the "Independent Review Team" who produced the report, and the local Evening Chronicle newspaper for libel.[25] Awarding Reed and Lillie the maximum possible damages of £200,000 each, the judge in the case made a "very rare" finding of "malice" on the part of the Independent Review Team, in that "they included in their report a number of fundamental claims which they must have known to be untrue and which cannot be explained on the basis of incompetence or mere carelessness." One of the four people on the Independent Review Team was Campbell's close working partner Judith Jones (see above), who was previously involved in the Nottingham case.[26]

Writing on the Sally Clark case, Campbell rejected any feminist arguments based on the "suspicion that medical men play God and pathologise women's distress". Such feminist arguments, she thought, ignored women's psychoses, or what Campbell called "the dangerousness of motherhood: it can make some women lose their minds, it makes some mothers murderous."[27] These speculations about Clark's mental state proved unfounded, however, as she was cleared of murder on appeal. In 2007 Campbell defended paediatrician David Southall, whose involvement in the Clark case was being investigated by the General Medical Council, saying "David Southall established a gold standard in the detection of lethal child abuse."[28] Southall was struck off the Medical Register for gross professional misconduct.[29] However, Dr Southall is back on the medical register after winning an appeal against this decision in a higher court. The Appeal Court's decision means he is able to practise medicine again

Honours and citations

Campbell has received several citations and awards from British universities. She is an Honorary Doctor of Letters at Salford University, an Honorary Doctor of Letters at Oxford Brookes University and an Honorary Doctor of Letters at the Open University. She was awarded a Simon Fellowship from Manchester University.

Her journalism has gained several awards both for Campbell’s books and newspaper articles. She was awarded the Cheltenham Literature Festival Prize in 1984 for her book Wigan Pier Revisited and the Fawcett Society Prize for her book The Iron Ladies. Campbell was named Campaigning Journalist of the Year by the 300 Group, an initiative to get more women into Parliament founded by Lesley Abdela, and later involving Elizabeth Vallance and Shirley Williams. Her Dispatches documentary "Listen to the Children" resulted in her receiving the Independent Television Producers First Time Producers award.

In June 2009 Campbell was made an OBE. She argued that "by clinging to symbols and rituals that belong to a cruel imperial order the government compromises the gonged" but defended herself on the grounds "getting gonged confers recognition of 'citizens' contributions' to a good society – in my case equality – and the gesture affirms our necessity; the radicals – not the royalists – are the best of the British".[30]

Publications

References

  1. ^ Ms Beatrix Campbell, OBE Authorised Biography – Debrett’s People of Today, Ms Beatrix Campbell, OBE Profile
  2. ^ a b "Beatrix Campbell: Out & out betrayal". The Independent (London). 2006-01-29. http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/beatrix-campbell-out-amp-out-betrayal-524933.html. Retrieved 2010-04-26. 
  3. ^ Campbell, Beatrix (2008-06-09). "<img class="contributor-pic" src="http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Guardian/Pix/pictures/2008/06/04/Beatrix_Campbell_140x140.jpg" alt="Picture of Beatrix Campbell" title="Beatrix Campbell" />". The Guardian (London). http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/beatrix_campbell/profile.html. 
  4. ^ Beatrix Campbell biography
  5. ^ Burke's Peerage - Preview Family Record
  6. ^ Williams, Granville (2008-02-12). "Obituary: Jimmy Barnes". The Guardian (London). http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2008/feb/12/tradeunions.pressandpublishing. 
  7. ^ http://menmedia.co.uk/accringtonobserver/life_and_style/announcements/s/1031582_jimmy_barnes
  8. ^ The Independent (London). 2006-01-29. http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/beatrix-campbell-out-amp-out-betrayal-524933.html. 
  9. ^ Brown, Rob (1997-10-06). The Independent (London). http://www.independent.co.uk/news/media/media-you-have-to-be-married-to-the-job-to-succeed-in-this-business-theyd-say-to-back-it-up-the-more-cultured-broadsheet-types-might-quote-yeats-1234269.html. 
  10. ^ Jack, Ian (1997-09-30). The Independent (London). http://www.independent.co.uk/news/obituaries/obituary-bobby-campbell-1242079.html. 
  11. ^ the witchfinder; She believes satanic abuse is common. So does her feminist Marxist lover. Was she really, then, the right person to sit in judgment on two nursery nurses fals...
  12. ^ http://menmedia.co.uk/accringtonobserver/life_and_style/announcements/s/1031582_jimmy_barnes
  13. ^ Geoff Andrews Endgames and New Times, p. 63
  14. ^ Geoff Andrews Endgames and New Times,p. 144
  15. ^ Bremner, Charles (2007-10-28). "I was stupid too but at least I admit it comrade". The Times (London). http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article2752164.ece. 
  16. ^ Gay Left no.4, Summer 1977 p 11
  17. ^ Gay Left no.4, Summer 1977 p 12
  18. ^ Beatrix Campbell The Road to Wigan Pier Revisited: Poverty and Politics in the 80s, Virago, 1984, p 210.
  19. ^ Beatrix Campbell "Kings of the Road", Marxism Today, December 1991, p 20-23, 23
  20. ^ Marxism Today, October 1990 http://www.amielandmelburn.org.uk/collections/authorsandtitles/mt/90_10_04.htm
  21. ^ Government Equalities Office Press release Sep 2008 http://www.equalities.gov.uk/news/prpage16.htm
  22. ^ Guardian article, July 2009 http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/libertycentral/2009/jul/16/children-childprotection
  23. ^ Greens’ author goes for Glenda seat http://www.thecnj.com/camden/2009/110509/news110509_10.html?headline=Greens%E2%80%99_author_goes_for_Glenda_seat
  24. ^ Beatrix Campbell "Seen but not Heard", Marxism Today, November 1990, p20-22, 20.
  25. ^ Bob Woffinden and Richard Webster (2002-08-02). "Cleared". London: The Guardian. http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2002/jul/31/childrensservices.childprotection. Retrieved 2010-08-13. 
  26. ^ The Honourable Mr Justice Eady's judgement: Part 1, Part 2, Part 3
  27. ^ Beatrix Campbell "The Baby Battleground", The Guardian, May 7, 2005, as reproduced on the Prisontalk website.
  28. ^ Comment Is Free, The Guardian, 'The unbearable heaviness of knowing', Beatrix Campbell, 21 February 2007
  29. ^ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7127485.stm + "David Southall struck off by GMC"]. BBC. 2007-12-04 +. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7127485.stm +. Retrieved 4 December 2007. 
  30. ^ Beatrix Campbell "Why I accepted my OBE", The Guardian, 16 June 2009

External links